Risk Management · 2024
In this section3 topics
Risk Management Policy & Plan
Main Introduction
Don Muang Tollway Public Company Limited and its subsidiaries recognize the importance of risk management in today's rapidly changing environment and unpredictable landscape. The company acknowledges the complexity and uncertainty of events that could potentially impact its business each year. Don Muang Tollway believes that enterprise-wide risk management will enable the company to achieve its sustainable business plan and goals, both in the short and long term.
Policy & Plan Description
The company recognizes the importance of systematic risk management under the principles of good corporate governance and ethical business conduct. This approach supports efficient operations, achievement of defined goals, and adaptability to rapidly changing circumstances and challenges arising from both internal and external factors. It also enhances opportunities for business growth. The company has established a risk management policy under its corporate governance policy and utilizes various risk management tools, such as risk assessment and ranking, risk management monitoring through mitigation plans, and the definition of Key Risk Indicators (KRIs). The company strives to develop risk management that encompasses all activities throughout the business value chain and promotes it as part of the company's work culture. Furthermore, the company monitors changes in critical external factors, including emerging risks, enabling proactive risk management measures before they impact company operations.
Policy Document Link
https://www.tollway.co.th/storage/document/cg/dmt-risk-management-en.pdf
Risk Factors — Overview
Risk Factors — Introduction
In 2024, the company operates in a rapidly changing, complex, and unpredictable environment, facing both internal and external challenges that could impact its ability to achieve the objectives outlined in its Sustainability Business Plan. To navigate these uncertainties, the company has conducted a business environment analysis, considering both past events and future projections for 2024. This assessment identifies key risk factors from both internal and external sources, as outlined below:
Risks to the Company's Business Operations
Risk Register
| Risk Name | Risk Characteristics | Consequences | Related Risk Factors |
|---|---|---|---|
| Risks arising from administrative lawsuits of the Company as a defendant | The Company agreed to enter into the Original Tollway concession contract with the Department of Highways on 21 August 1989. The Department of Highways granted the Company with the rights to utilize concession areas, invest, design, construct, maintain, operate the concession highway and relevant facilities, as well as the rights to increase and collect toll fees as stipulated in the Concession Highway Act B.E. 2473 (1930). Later, the Company and the Department of Highways agreed to amend the Tollway Concession Agreement for a total of 3 times as follows: 1st Amendment: on 27 April 1995, according to the memorandum agreement amending the highway concession agreement no. 1/1995 (“MOA 1/1995”), the Company registered for a name change and transformed into a public company. In addition, the Board of Investment Promotion has approved investment for the concession highway project. Under the Company’s terms and conditions, benefits must be offered to the Department of Highways and the government in addition to those specified in the Original Tollway Concession Agreement. 2nd Amendment: on 29 November 1996, according to the memorandum agreement amending the highway concession agreement no. 2/1996 (“MOA 2/1996”), the Department of Highways wanted to resolve traffic congestion in front of Bangkok Don Muang International Airport and on Viphavadi Rangsit Road with increasing traffic volume, as well as to correct the financial position of the Company which was damaged due to the state’s inability to perform the conditions as specified in the Original Highway Concession Agreement. As a result, the Department of Highways has granted the Company additional highway concession rights for the Northern Extension, starting from the front of Don Muang Airport to the front of the Royal Thai Air Force at the National Memorial. The Original Tollway concession and the Northern Extension concession have the same concession period, expiring at the same time after 25 years from the date of MOA 2/1996. The Company has the rights to collect tolls and adjust the toll rates of the Original Tollway and the Northern Extension as stipulated in MOA 2/1996. 3rd Amendment: on 12 September 2007, according to the memorandum agreement amending the highway concession agreement no. 3/2007 (“MOA 3/2007”), to solve the Company’s financial loss due to the state’s inability to perform the conditions as specified in the Original Highway Concession Agreement and MOA 2/1996. According to the agreement to amend the negative effects on the Company’s financial position of Article 25 of the Original Highway Concession Agreement, the Department of Highways has agreed to extend the concession period of the Original Tollway and the Northern Extension to 27 years from the date of MOA 3/2007, whereby the Company has the rights to adjust the toll rates according to Clause 5 of MOA 3/2007 as follow: “the toll rates to be collected from all types of vehicles shall be in accordance with the Toll Rate Schedule below, which shall come into immediate effect by way of adjustment of the toll rates according to this Schedule, without the Concessionaire being required to obtain any permission from the DOH again, but subject to the Concessionaire giving at least 30 (thirty) days’ notice. The Concessionaire shall announce and publicize it to the public for a reasonable amount of time in advance. These toll rates are inclusive of 7% VAT.” Since the Company and the Department of Highways has agreed on MOA 3/2007, the Company has adjusted the toll rates 4 times and according to the Toll Rate Schedule above, which has caused the Company 3 legal disputes with the Administrative Court, consisting of 1 case of toll adjustment since 22 December 2007 and 2 cases of toll adjustment since 22 December 2009, with the status of each case summarized as follows: Administrative case no. 1: dispute of the red case no. Aor. 43/2016, which is a dispute occurred when the Company implemented the adjustment of toll rates according to MOA 3/2007 from 22 December 2007. On 10 January 2008, a total of 3 plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against the Company and 3 other public defendants to the Central Administrative Court, requesting the Central Administrative Court to revoke the announcement of the Director of Concession Highways, dated 14 December 2007 and, and requested the Court to demand the 3 defendants to collect tolls at the same rate before 22 December 2007. The Central Administrative Court issued a judgment on 10 August 2010 to dismiss the case, and the Supreme Administrative Court’s judgment on 19 April 2016 dismissed the case as well, the key reason being that the MOA 3/2007 was legally prepared. At the present, the case has reached its final status according to the law. Administrative case no. 2 : dispute of the red case no. Aor. 1563/2016 which is a dispute occurred when the Company implemented the adjustment of toll rates according to MOA 3/2007 from 22 December 2007. On 11 December 2009, 2 plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against the Company and 4 other public defendants to the Central Administrative Court, requesting the Central Administrative Court to revoke the Cabinet’s approval of agreement renewal between the Department of Highways and the Company because they did not follow the rules of the law. If the Court deems that the renewal of agreement under MOA 3/2007 is legal, the plaintiffs request the Court to consider whether the toll increase is appropriate for economic conditions. The Central Administrative Court issued a verdict on 29 March 2012 to dismiss the case and the Supreme Administrative Court also dismissed the case on 10 January 2017, with the key reason being that the MOA 3/2007 was legally prepared and the Cabinet’s resolution on 10 April 2007 approved MOA 3/2007 in accordance with the legal procedures. At the present, the case has reached its final status according to the law. Administrative case no. 3: dispute of the black case no. Aor. 1187-1188/2015 which is a dispute occurred when the Company implemented the adjustment of toll rates according to MOA 3/2007 from 22 December 2007. On 24 December 2009, the Central Administrative Court issued an order accepting a plaintiff’s compliant that have filed a lawsuit against the Company and other public defendants, a total of 4 cases, requesting to revoke the Cabinet resolutions on 11 April 2006 and 10 April 2007, which approved the preparation of the MOA 3/2007. Later, on 26 November 2014, the Central Administrative Court consolidated this case with another case of 20 plaintiffs filing a lawsuit against 3 public defendants to the Central Administrative Court requesting to revoke the same Cabinet’s resolutions. The Central Administrative Court issued a verdict on 18 August 2015 to revoke the Cabinet’s resolutions on 11 April 2006 and 10 April 2007 in approving the preparation of MOA 3/2007. According to the Central Administrative Court’s reading of the Supreme Administrative Court’s judgment red case no. Aor. 85-85/2023 on 24 February 2023, with the Supreme Administrative Court overturning the verdict. The Administrative Court of First Instance dismissed the plaintiff’s case. As a result of this judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court, the dispute regarding the legality of the Cabinet resolution approving the agreement to make MOA 3/2007 has ended and has reached the legal end. The judgment of the said case also resulted in the dispute regarding the application of toll rates according to the Company’s highway concession contract. All three cases have been completed and have been finalized according to the law. | However, even though the three existing lawsuits regarding toll rate adjustments under the concession agreement have been fully settled and concluded, the company still faces the risk of potential new lawsuits related to future toll adjustments. This is particularly relevant for the next two toll rate adjustments scheduled for the periods between December 22, 2024, to December 21, 2029, and December 22, 2029, to the end of the concession period (September 11, 2034). In order to manage legal risks related to new administrative cases that may arise, the Company has legal opinion to support it. In other words, the Company can refer to the Supreme Administrative Court judgments in all three cases. It is facts and evidence to fight the case that may be filed as a new case. The Company is able to use the decision of the Supreme Administrative Court in all three cases, which a decision regarding the legality of the application of toll rates according to the highway concession contract and the completion of MOA 3/2007 in all aspects for use as facts and evidence to fight new cases that may be filed further in the future, including results of the Administrative Court’s judgment in the case that the Company’s additional lawsuit may be filed, which are unlikely to conflict with the Supreme Administrative Court’s judgments in all three cases. Currently, in the third administrative case, the Supreme Administrative Court has overturned the ruling of the Lower Administrative Court and dismissed the case. This ruling legally concludes and finalizes the dispute regarding the legality of the Cabinet resolution approving the execution of MOA 3/2550. As a result, the original parties to the case can no longer file a lawsuit on the same dispute. | 1723 · Description: Legal risk · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 736 · Description: Damage to company image and reputation · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Risks from inability to collect tolls at the pre-determined rates | In MOA No.3/2007 between Department of Highways and the Company stated an important clause regarding Pre-Determined Toll Rates1. When the pre-determined date arrives, the new toll rates will be immediately in effective without further approval by Department of Highways. However, the Company must announce and publicize to the public reasonably in advance per Clause 5 of the MOA 3/2007. Even though, the Company has accepted the conditions and was able to collect new toll rates per MOA 3/2007 for the total of 4 times on 22 December of years 2007, 2009, 2014 and 2019, respectively. The collections of new toll rates in 2007 and 2009 resulted in groups of plaintiffs filed filing complaints at the Central Administrative Court against the state agencies along with the Company for the total of 3 cases. One case is a complaint for collecting the new toll rates started on 22 December 2007. While other complaints for collecting new toll rates on 22 December 2009 for 2 cases which makes to the total of 3 cases. These complaints have the intention for an order to revoke toll collection under the new rates and revert to toll rates per Memorandum of Agreement amending the Highway Concession Agreement No.2/1996. Later, the Supreme Administrative Court, had ruling to dismiss the Case 1 and Case 2, and kept the remaining Case 3. In this case, the 3rd administrative case has important issues that the Supreme Administrative Court has made a final decision as follows: - In the matter of preparing MOA 3/2007, it is in accordance with the steps required by law. - Toll rates according to MOA 3/2007 do not create an unreasonable burden on the people. | The toll rates were determined in accordance to the Memorandum of Agreement amending the Highway Concession Agreement No. 3/2007 at the latest on 22 December 2014, no one filed complaints against the Company nor state agencies. During the toll collection with the pre-determined new toll rates and time in advance per toll rate schedule as indicated in the Memorandum of Agreement amending the Highway Concession Agreement No. 3/2007, on 22 December 2019, the Foundation for Consumers along with 20 associates had filed a request to emergency review and temporary relief where the Supreme Court has rejected such request before ruling. The Company, with the Company’s Legal Advisor’s opinions regarding the administrative cases, believes that in the future, there should not be any administrative case filing for collecting the new toll rates as pre-determined in MOA 3/2007 since the Supreme Court has final ruling for the case for collecting of new toll rates in 2019 above. The Company is confident that the collection of new toll rates as stated in the MOA 3/2007 in the future should not make any complications in terms of administrative case. As of 31 December 2024, the Company is collecting at rates determined in MOA 3/2007. | 756 · Description: Change in laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 1723 · Description: Legal risk · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK |
| Risks of not having new projects when the concession period expires | The Company operates its main business as a concessionaire for the construction and service of the Don Muang Tollway, Din Daeng – National Memorial section, under the tollway concession agreement in respect of the highway no. 31, with the concession period until 11 September 2034. At present, the Company is in the process of acquiring new projects with the main income solely from operations of the Don Muang Tollway. If the Company fails to acquire new projects or renew this concession agreement within 11 September 2034, there may be risks of not having new projects to operate and may cause the business to be dissolved once the concession agreement expires. If there is a need to liquidate the business, the Company will proceed to pay dividends from retained earnings to shareholders in accordance with the dividend payment policy. The Company will have more cash than retained earnings that will be used for dividend payment. Since the amortization of concession costs for using the Don Muang Tollway is a non-cash expense, the Company’s net profit is lower than the operating cash flow received. Therefore, liquidation will be carried out to use remaining cash of the Company for disposing capital back to shareholders in proportion to their shareholding. In 2021, the Company used proceeds from the sale of 140 million newly issued shares to repay long-term and short-term loans with interest to financial institutions in the amount of Baht 1,686.36 million on 10 May 2021. As a result, the Company has no debt burden, long-term and short-term loans with financial institutions, and the debt to equity ratio as of 31 December 2021 was equal to 0.07 times. However, without investment in new projects, it is unnecessary to incur interest-bearing debts. In this regard, the Company is striving to inquire new projects, including making a proposal at least 5 years before the concession period expires in accordance with Section 49 of the Public-Private Partnership Act B.E. 2562 (2019), which requires the project owner (Department of Highways) to prepare a guideline for continuing the PPP project after the agreement expires. Comparisons between the cases where government agencies operate solely and where it is a joint partnership of public and private sectors is to be proposed to the Minister of Transport at least 5 years prior to the expiration of the concession agreement by taking into consideration state benefits, continuity of public service, and impact on the people. For the case of joint partnership, after the Department of Highways has proposed to the Minister of Transport regarding the guidelines and the Minister of Transport has approved of the joint partnership, the Department of Highways will proceed with project presentation and select the private sector for concessionaire. In case where the private sector has been selected to operate the Don Muang Tollway after the concession ends, the Company has an advantage in making a bid proposal to become the operator of the Don Muang Tollway Project after the concession contract expires in 2034. This is mainly due to the Company’s expertise in management of the Don Muang Tollway since the beginning of its construction in 1989, making it knowledgeable and understanding of the project with information on quantity and traffic behaviors of the project and its adjacent areas. At present, however, the Department of Highways has yet to conduct a study on how the project will be operated after the concession agreement expires. Therefore, there is still uncertainty about the management approach, including guidelines for sharing benefits between DOH and private sector, which can be in any form and not limited PPP Net Cost concession where the private sector collects and owns the toll revenue with appropriate compensation to the Department of Highways in the form of concession fees or revenue sharing, etc., or PPP Gross Cost where the private sector collects toll and forward to the Department of Highways and the private sector receives compensation from DOH as agreed, or administrative agreements, etc. Each model has different income characteristics in terms of both income opportunities and risks, which is still currently unpredictable until further study has been conducted and granting approval according to procedures has been completed up to the Cabinet resolution. In addition, the Company has also conducted a feasibility study of new projects continuously according to the Company’s annual business plan having the Business Development Working Team and the New Project Development Working Team perform nominating and studying of projects related to concession business on operation and maintenance, which aims to use the Company’s expertise in concession business and joining with partners to participate in bidding for new projects and investing in potential projects to generate income for the Company in order to ensure business sustainability. Since the Company has been operating the project for more than 30 years, it has deep knowledge and understanding of structures, operating guidelines, and management of a concession project according to the standards and requirements of the Department of Highways. Moreover, the Company has skilled and experienced personnel, making it a strong candidate for bidding in various projects under the Public-Private Partnership (PPP) policy. As for development of the current project, technological development has been implemented to respond to changes, needs, and expectations of all groups of stakeholders, as well as preparing for sustainable business expansion, for example, the Smart Project for installing traffic control equipment has been completed in 2021. In present, advanced technology is implemented to assist in the development of advanced video analytics program, or Deep Learning, for detection of vehicles and fallen objects. Regarding the toll collection system, in addition to installment of the ETC system that supports M Pass and Easy Pass, EMV and QR Code payment systems have been developed to support cashless society and to participate in the development by Demo Lane Testing of the M-Flow toll collection system according to the policy of the Department of Highways and the Ministry of Transport. This system has been installed at Din Daeng Toll Plaza for studying and Demo Lane testing. The Demo Lane test is expected to be concluded in 2022. In addition, at the Executive Committee Meeting No. 20/2021 on Wednesday, 27 October 2021, the management was assigned to study new other non-toll road business that are different from existing businesses to strengthen and generate income for the business. In terms of services, studies on assisting electric vehicles are being conducted in order to better serve electric vehicle users, of which are increasing at a rapid pace. This is to ensure that the Company has the ability to such users immediately and accurately. The Company has also installed an electric charging station and is also conducting studies on mobile assistive devices such as Mobile Charging. These initiatives are for the Company to develop unceasingly and to have the potential in becoming a preferable alternative for the Department of Highways to consider selecting the Company as the service provider after the concession agreement has expired for a seamless and continued public service. | The Company operates its main business as a concessionaire for the construction and service of the Don Muang Tollway, Din Daeng – National Memorial section, under the tollway concession agreement in respect of the highway no. 31, with the concession period until 11 September 2034. At present, the Company is in the process of acquiring new projects with the main income solely from operations of the Don Muang Tollway. If the Company fails to acquire new projects or renew this concession agreement within 11 September 2034, there may be risks of not having new projects to operate and may cause the business to be dissolved once the concession agreement expires. If there is a need to liquidate the business, the Company will proceed to pay dividends from retained earnings to shareholders in accordance with the dividend payment policy. The Company will have more cash than retained earnings that will be used for dividend payment. Since the amortization of concession costs for using the Don Muang Tollway is a non-cash expense, the Company’s net profit is lower than the operating cash flow received. Therefore, liquidation will be carried out to use remaining cash of the Company for disposing capital back to shareholders in proportion to their shareholding. | 1716 · Description: New business risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Risks from business operations under concession agreement with state agencies | The Company operates business under the Highway Concession Agreement under the supervision of the Department of Highways, which is a state agency with policies, laws and regulations considerably involved, as well as the administration of the public sector that may be affected by political changes that could result in changes in policies, laws, and regulations that may impact the Company’s management. To reduce such risk, the Company, the Department of Highways and other related state agencies have reviewed and complied with the Public-Private Partnership Act B.E.2562, effective on 11 March 2019 replacing the Private Investments in State Undertakings Act B.E.2556 and the Act on Private Participation in State Undertakings B.E.2535 on 4 April 2013, aiming to monitor the situation and the progress of operations and jointly solve problems that may arise from policy changes by the State with closely, continuously and regularly coordination. With regards to the Company operations, the Company holds at least one Board of Directors’ meeting in every 3 months, 4 sessions of Risk Management Committee’s meetings per year, and 2 sessions of Management Committee’s meetings (Executive Committee) every month, to review the policies, strategies, and business plans to suit the policies, laws, and regulations that may undergo changes, for best benefits of Public-Private Partnership (PPP) in the long run. The Don Muang Tollway is a Public-Private Partnership with Infrastructure value exceeding Baht 5,000 million which is obligated to be in compliance to the Public-Private Partnership Act B.E.2562 intended to reduce the investment burden on the state, to increase the investment capability and operation management, to receive technology transfer including expand the scope and increase the quality for public services. Therefore, as the concession approaches an expiration, the Department of Highways is required to fabricate a report and analyze the project as stipulated by Section 49 of the Public-Private Partnership Act B.E.2562 which appointed the project-handling agency (Department of Highways) to prepare directions for the operation of the project in furtherance of the partnership project after the termination of the partnership agreement, on the basis of a comparison of the case where the State agency undertakes it and the case where a private party is allowed to enter into partnership, for submission to the minister of the responsible ministry at least 5 years prior to the termination of the partnership agreement, having regard to interests of the State, continuity of the delivery of public services and impacts on the public. The Department of Highways’ policy is quite certain that the project will be a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) project in order to reduce the burden of the national budget and to provide the utmost benefit for the government and the public. Therefore, there is a possibility that the government may choose to implement the project in the form of PPP, which must be operated as if a new joint venture project by bidding to select a private entity for concession. The Company has been operating the project for over 30 years with good knowledge and understanding on structure and guidelines on operation and management of the project in accordance with standards and requirements of DOH. There is also a continuous improvement in many aspects of Operation & Maintenance, which will be beneficial to the government due to the continuity of public service and impacts on people. | The Company operates business under the Highway Concession Agreement under the supervision of the Department of Highways, which is a state agency with policies, laws and regulations considerably involved, as well as the administration of the public sector that may be affected by political changes that could result in changes in policies, laws, and regulations that may impact the Company’s management. To reduce such risk, the Company, the Department of Highways and other related state agencies have reviewed and complied with the Public-Private Partnership Act B.E.2562, effective on 11 March 2019 replacing the Private Investments in State Undertakings Act B.E.2556 and the Act on Private Participation in State Undertakings B.E.2535 on 4 April 2013, aiming to monitor the situation and the progress of operations and jointly solve problems that may arise from policy changes by the State with closely, continuously and regularly coordination. | 728 · Description: Volatility in the industry in which the company operates · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Risks from economic and political uncertainties | Due to volatility and uncertainty of the economic and political conditions in Thailand, current regional and global economies, and the war between Russia and Ukraine, oil prices, inflation, and economic growth are factors that affect the country’s consumption. However, when compared to traffic volumes on Don Muang Tollway, the impacts are relatively low generally because the Company’s revenue growth was higher than that of Thailand’s inflation rate. COVID-19 pandemic, on the other hand, had greater impact on the Company’s performance than did economic and political factors due to factors concerning travel restrictions. However, after the outbreak of COVID-19, various factors have changed, leading to continued impacts beyond just economic and political factors. Regarding the volatility of oil prices, which affects users due to increased travel costs, this may impact traffic volume during periods of high oil prices. However, some users still see the Don Muang Tollway as a cost-effective option due to shorter travel times, reduced vehicle wear and tear, and less stressful travel. Although oil prices have risen significantly since 2022 due to the Russia-Ukraine war and high demand from the recovering global economy, management continues to monitor oil prices and the impact of the war on these prices, as discussed in the 2024 Risk Management Committee meetings. The government has issued policies to help reduce PM 2.5 dust pollution and greenhouse gas emissions on the roads by encouraging the production and usage of electric vehicles. Currently, the government encourages changing from general combustion cars to electric cars with a policy to promote the electric car industry and aiming to produce EVs in the proportion of 30% of all domestic car production by the year 2030 in order to push and be a part of driving Thailand toward a low carbon society. The Board of Investment or BOI supports investments in production of EVs and related equipment such as businesses producing electric cars, batteries, and charging stations. The Ministry of Industry encourages producers of electric cars and related equipment such as activities for producing electric vehicle battery, traction motor, battery management system, charger, charging station, etc. The Ministry of Finance supports tax measures and subsidize those who buy full EV cars to reduce the prices of CV cars in the first 5 years from 2022, which subsidizing has enabled price reduction from the domestic competitiveness development fund. In addition, the Royal Decree on reduction of annual tax for electric vehicles 2022, section 3 states the annual tax reduction for electric vehicles, which are a new car finished from the factory registered within a period of 3 years from the date this Royal Decree comes into force by 80% of the rate prescribe. This is similar to the first car policy previously supported by the government. Therefore, the Company has a policy to encourage the use of EV cars such as charging stations preparation, conducting studies to use electric cars for the Company’s activities e.g. executive cars or operating vehicles, etc. | Due to volatility and uncertainty of the economic and political conditions in Thailand, current regional and global economies, and the war between Russia and Ukraine, oil prices, inflation, and economic growth are factors that affect the country’s consumption. However, when compared to traffic volumes on Don Muang Tollway, the impacts are relatively low generally because the Company’s revenue growth was higher than that of Thailand’s inflation rate. COVID-19 pandemic, on the other hand, had greater impact on the Company’s performance than did economic and political factors due to factors concerning travel restrictions. However, after the outbreak of COVID-19, various factors have changed, leading to continued impacts beyond just economic and political factors. | 1715 · Description: Economic risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Risks from the Red Line Mass Transit Network | The Company’s main business is transportation service provider for people travelling in and out of the Northern Bangkok Metropolitan area, which is the main route leading to upper central, northern, and northeastern regions. The Company takes into account the risks from increasing electric train network, especially the Red Line, which may negatively impact its management, income, and operations. From monitoring the traffic volume of the Red Line electric train next to Don Muang Tollway, the Ministry of Transport has a policy to support travelling by electric train. On 16 October 2023, the Cabinet approved the Baht 20 electric train policy, piloting 2 routes first, namely the purple and red lines. The management is closely monitoring how much effect this change in travel patterns will have. However, analysis from experts suggested that Red Line users are different from Don Muang Tollway users and that it is discovered that travel expenses for Red Line users include connecting trips and access to stations through feeder. Although the electric train fare has been reduced to Baht 20 per person per trip, there are other factors to be considered for travel costs with fares connecting to other transportation systems, such as motorcycle taxis, minibuses, buses to other lines. Therefore, the average cost per person is still higher than using the tollway. Studies by the Company’s traffic experts have shown that it is inconclusive how much impact the Red Line will have on toll users because most electric train users are of different target segment of the toll users. In addition, fee is another to consider when choosing different forms of transportation, in which electric train users must take into account the cost of feeder when choosing the Red Line and may add up to be similar to that of using the Don Muang Tollway, including travel behaviors that prefer door-to-door instead of making transits and thus by car is still a preferable mode of transportation. Although more electric trains have become available, road traffics continue to be highly congested. This is mainly due to the supply side, or roads, cannot be easily constructed because of limited pieces of land in Bangkok. Meanwhile, traffic volumes or car sales on the demand side is still the main mode of transportation. In conclusion, the tollway is still an alternative way for easy, fast, and safe travels. | The Company’s main business is transportation service provider for people travelling in and out of the Northern Bangkok Metropolitan area, which is the main route leading to upper central, northern, and northeastern regions. The Company takes into account the risks from increasing electric train network, especially the Red Line, which may negatively impact its management, income, and operations. | 730 · Description: Government policy · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Service risks | The Company takes into consideration operational risk that may arise from the Company’s personnel, operating system, work process, and information technology system, which may cause loss in both monetary and non-monetary terms. The Company employs strict controls and cautions, with units responsible for repair and maintenance of the Tollway and the toll collection system, under the supervision of the Management and employee with experience and expertise, to ensure quality and readiness in providing complete and continuous services efficiently in accordance with ISO 9001:2015 standards of quality management system and ISO 14001:2015 standards of environmental management system. The results of Project of Inspection and Assessment for Tollway Elevated Structure revealed no significant damages that may affect the stability of the structure, only deterioration from general use. The Company have used these results for making effective and continuous plans for monitoring and maintaining Don Muang Tollway. The toll collection, communication and traffic control systems are crucial to business operations and receive preventive maintenance having plans for checking the systems and equipment with a data and power back up systems. Including the actual use of the BCP plan when power outage occurred affecting the toll collection system at Ratchadaphisek Toll Plaza on 7 December 2024. | The Company takes into consideration operational risk that may arise from the Company’s personnel, operating system, work process, and information technology system, which may cause loss in both monetary and non-monetary terms. The Company employs strict controls and cautions, with units responsible for repair and maintenance of the Tollway and the toll collection system, under the supervision of the Management and employee with experience and expertise, to ensure quality and readiness in providing complete and continuous services efficiently in accordance with ISO 9001:2015 standards of quality management system and ISO 14001:2015 standards of environmental management system. | 755 · Other name: Operational risks · Description: Other · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Risk from natural disaster and emergency cases | In case of emergency, such as major accident, disaster, terrorism, sabotage, riot, political rally, protest, car parking on the Tollway without a proper reason, etc., the Company has prepared emergency plans to accommodate the events that may occur, including preparation for responsible staff and related personnel to perform duties in time of emergency. Besides, the Company has taken measures to patrol the Tollway more often, including coordination with the police in the area. Additionally, the Company has adjusted the locations and added equipment and devices on the Tollway, to enhance monitoring control and surveillance capabilities such as the installation of crash cushions, CCTVs, lightings, traffic signs, and warning signs for tollway users. With the commitment to enhance the operation capabilities to perform duties with prompt, high efficiency and accuracy, including providing better information to tollway users, the Company has studied methods to improve the traffic control management & surveillance system with Metropolitan Expressway Co., Ltd., an expert in expressway services on elevated expressways, at-grade expressways, and tunnel expressways of a total length about 300 km in Tokyo, Japan. Currently, the Company has started the project in 2017 and the system has gone live in August 2021. The Company has acquired insurance to cover damages that may occur to Don Muang Tollway, including toll control buildings, office buildings, toll booths and all assets used in the business (All Risks Insurance), damages to the tollway structures (Property Damage), inability to continue the business (Business Interruption), cash stored at the toll Plaza and offices (Money Insurance), assets and equipment in the office (Property Damage to Office Equipment), and damage to the public (Public Liability), for the purpose of minimizing damage to Don Muang Tollway by uncontrollable incidents on a yearly basis. Moreover, Business Continuity Plan (BCP) is constantly reviewed and rehearsed. An emergency and business continuity management team was established. The BCP is rehearsed in the event of an electric car having a short circuit from the system at the MOC building parking lot on 25 July 2024. | In case of emergency, such as major accident, disaster, terrorism, sabotage, riot, political rally, protest, car parking on the Tollway without a proper reason, etc., the Company has prepared emergency plans to accommodate the events that may occur, including preparation for responsible staff and related personnel to perform duties in time of emergency. Besides, the Company has taken measures to patrol the Tollway more often, including coordination with the police in the area. Additionally, the Company has adjusted the locations and added equipment and devices on the Tollway, to enhance monitoring control and surveillance capabilities such as the installation of crash cushions, CCTVs, lightings, traffic signs, and warning signs for tollway users. | 749 · Description: Safety, occupational health, and working environment · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 750 · Description: Climate change and disasters · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Personnel, occupational health and safety risks | Personnel are a key element in business operations. The Company has prepared the organization in terms of people, organization, and culture in order to support business model and working styles that have changed to be efficient, as well as driving Digital Transformation to enhance efficiency and strengthen competitiveness in a concrete way to grow with stability in the long-term. The Company has set directions for human resources development system to be in line with its business strategies by offering e-Learning according to functional competency, promoting working team to achieve team goals, providing opportunities for career advancement and business continuity. Due to the global effect from COVID-19 and its impact on the Company, the Company has developed itself to become a resilient organization focusing on work processes that are compact, fast, flexible, and ability to cope with crisis or unusual events in order to effectively drive the Company’s strategies towards success and sustainable growth. The Company places emphasis on appropriate and fair remuneration, skills and knowledge development, and work safety by taking into account human rights of personnel throughout the organization. Also, personnel are encouraged to express their creativity and initiate new ideas for work under their responsibilities through activities of the personnel development program. The Company grants scholarships to entry-level executives to pursue a Master’s Degree, organizes appropriate training courses, and creates an environment of family-like teams. The Company believes that good working environment and atmosphere will help foster relationships between personnel and the organization, as well as retaining personnel with potential, which is a part of human resources development plan for succession. As Thailand is entering an aging population, the working-age population is declining which may lead to labor shortages in the future. In order to reduce personnel risks and turnovers, a managed services policy is implemented in accordance with business operations. These factors are conducive for reducing personnel risks. Emphasize on safety and occupational health of all personnel during the severe outbreaks of COVID-19 by preparing and adjusting guidelines of occupational health and safety for personnel so that they can operate and carry out business activities safely, in compliance with the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2011 and the laws, rules, and regulations on the management of COVID-19, which were strictly stipulated. The Company gives importance to safety, occupational health and working environment of the Company, as well as its employees, contractors or partners. The Company has a policy on safety, occupational health and working environment by assigning employees and contractors to be responsible for themselves and others under administrative laws and standards. The Company established the Occupational Safety, Health and Environment (OSH&E) Committee program, which convenes once a month with the goal to have zero accidents at work. When causes of danger are found, work plans are adjusted to prevent recurring accidents, which is to analyze the real cause of accidents, improving the operating manual, and applying ISO 45001:2018 standards to determine management guidelines to prevent and reduce operational accidents. Moreover, the Company organized safety promotion activities for employees of all levels and partners/contractors to be conscious of safety, to have knowledge and understanding of safety on a daily basis, as well as announcing the responsibilities of those whose duties are related to safety at work for employees of all levels to understand the scope of their responsibilities regarding safety, health, and working environment as specified in the security policy annually. Fire fighting drills and fire evacuation drills are carried out together at least once a year. | Personnel are a key element in business operations. The Company has prepared the organization in terms of people, organization, and culture in order to support business model and working styles that have changed to be efficient, as well as driving Digital Transformation to enhance efficiency and strengthen competitiveness in a concrete way to grow with stability in the long-term. The Company has set directions for human resources development system to be in line with its business strategies by offering e-Learning according to functional competency, promoting working team to achieve team goals, providing opportunities for career advancement and business continuity. Due to the global effect from COVID-19 and its impact on the Company, the Company has developed itself to become a resilient organization focusing on work processes that are compact, fast, flexible, and ability to cope with crisis or unusual events in order to effectively drive the Company’s strategies towards success and sustainable growth. | 749 · Description: Safety, occupational health, and working environment · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Cyber threat risks | The Company places great importance on cyber threat risks because they have significant impact on the Company’s operations, especially important systems such as finance and accounting, procurement, management, including toll collection and personal information that the Company holds. If problems occur with the information technology system, especially access to personal information that the Company possesses as a Data Controller, will surely affect its operations and reputation. Therefore, a systematic plan to prevent risks from cyber threats has been established by defining cyber and information security policies with cyber-attack response procedures as guidelines for relevant personnel to understand their roles in responding to such incidents. In addition, vulnerability scan (VA) by external contractors is performed annually and the results are used for continually improving the information system and practices. The Company invests in development of operation systems to support new technologies such as maintaining the computer network system to always be available, as well as having a systematic backup system, a main Data Center (DC), and a Disaster Recovery Center (DR) with a protection against unauthorized access or identity theft by establishing strict security control measures such as firewall, rights to access data, and networking of DR to support emergencies and the Disaster Recovery Plan (DRP) is rehearsed annually to ensure business continuity. | The Company places great importance on cyber threat risks because they have significant impact on the Company’s operations, especially important systems such as finance and accounting, procurement, management, including toll collection and personal information that the Company holds. If problems occur with the information technology system, especially access to personal information that the Company possesses as a Data Controller, will surely affect its operations and reputation. Therefore, a systematic plan to prevent risks from cyber threats has been established by defining cyber and information security policies with cyber-attack response procedures as guidelines for relevant personnel to understand their roles in responding to such incidents. In addition, vulnerability scan (VA) by external contractors is performed annually and the results are used for continually improving the information system and practices. The Company invests in development of operation systems to support new technologies such as maintaining the computer network system to always be available, as well as having a systematic backup system, a main Data Center (DC), and a Disaster Recovery Center (DR) with a protection against unauthorized access or identity theft by establishing strict security control measures such as firewall, rights to access data, and networking of DR to support emergencies and the Disaster Recovery Plan (DRP) is rehearsed annually to ensure business continuity. | 744 · Description: Information security and cyber-attack · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Personal data risks | In 2023, as the Data Controller Company, DMT has driven operations to be in accordance with the framework set forth in the Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562, including reviewing the Personal Data Protection Policy, reviewing and improving the privacy notice related to the Company’s various operating processes, covering all stakeholder groups. There are personal data protection officers, a policy for collection and destruction of personal data, a policy on sending or disclosing information to external or foreign agencies, a privacy policy for users of Smarter Tollway Mobile Application. Steps for handling problems with complaints and/or personal data breach incidents arise, including reviewing activities that are collected, used, or processed personal data through the preparation of a Personal Data Inventory Assessment jointly with personal data protection officers. Moreover, the Company has organized training for employees at the level of chiefs and executives to have knowledge and awareness of the importance of personal data protection by the Personal Data Protection Officer as a speaker. | In 2023, as the Data Controller Company, DMT has driven operations to be in accordance with the framework set forth in the Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562, including reviewing the Personal Data Protection Policy, reviewing and improving the privacy notice related to the Company’s various operating processes, covering all stakeholder groups. There are personal data protection officers, a policy for collection and destruction of personal data, a policy on sending or disclosing information to external or foreign agencies, a privacy policy for users of Smarter Tollway Mobile Application. Steps for handling problems with complaints and/or personal data breach incidents arise, including reviewing activities that are collected, used, or processed personal data through the preparation of a Personal Data Inventory Assessment jointly with personal data protection officers. Moreover, the Company has organized training for employees at the level of chiefs and executives to have knowledge and awareness of the importance of personal data protection by the Personal Data Protection Officer as a speaker. | 744 · Description: Information security and cyber-attack · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Risk of toll revenue being insufficient for the Company’s expenses | Toll revenue for the Don Muang Tollway under the Highway Concession Agreement is considered the Company’s main revenue. Therefore, if the Company is impacted by external factors that are uncontrollable by the Company, such as economic and political conditions, political rallies, oil prices, disasters, serious epidemics, etc., that may have significant impacts on traffic volumes on the Tollway and if the Company earns far less than the estimated revenue, it may affect the Company’s cash flow and financial liquidity, including the operating expenses under the Highway Concession Agreement. • Currently, the Company’s financial structure as of 31 December 2024, the Company has financial debt burdened with interest from drawing down working capital in the amount of 200 million Baht, with a debt-to-equity ratio (D/E Ratio) of 0.11 times, and the revolving line of credit for use in the business, which has not yet been disbursed, of 2,000 million Baht (31 December 2023: 900 million Baht). • The toll rates have been pre-determined according to the MOA 3/2007, dated 12 September 2007. The rates are scheduled to be collected at the new pre-determined rates on December 22 of 2007, 2009, 2014, 2019, 2019, 2024, and 2029 (every 5 years from 2009). The toll rates have been mutually agreed upon as properly calculated rates since the Company has already evaluated those risks from inability to collect pre-determined toll rates are relatively low as the toll has been successfully collected at the new rates for 4 times. • The company has continuously managed operating costs effectively, without impacting ongoing operations. Even during the COVID-19 crisis from 2020 to May 2022, the company successfully controlled and reduced expenses. In 2024, operating expenses, excluding concession fees, depreciation, and financial costs, accounted for 24.25% of total revenue. Financial costs decreased due to the use of proceeds from the initial public offering (IPO) of 140 million shares to repay long-term and short-term loans, including interest, to financial institutions amounting to 1,686.36 million baht on May 10, 2021. The company has invested in enhancing operational efficiency to adapt to various changes in technology, regulations, and user behavior. This includes the toll collection system, which now offers diverse payment methods to cater to consumer preferences. Other areas of improvement include the elevated road maintenance system, traffic management and facilitation systems, applications, and support systems. The company has undergone a digital transformation with RISE with SAP, upgrading services, developing personnel, and utilizing information technology innovations for internal systems. This includes the development of Robotic Process Automation (RPA) and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems. The company has also invested in energy-saving innovations. This includes installing solar rooftop systems at all nine toll plazas and the head office, online electricity meters in ten buildings, and energy-saving devices for streetlights on Uthraphimuk Elevated Road. The company is also implementing a solar energy storage battery project at the MOC building, which will be completed in the first quarter of 2025. Additionally, the company has installed EV charging stations at the head office and Din Daeng toll plaza to serve electric vehicle users on the tollway. The company has also transitioned to using electric vehicles (EVs) for replacements starting in 2024. • The company effectively manages financial costs and optimizes returns on investments. In 2024, the company generated 25.35 million baht in investment income and incurred 20.59 million baht in financial costs from utilizing short-term revolving credit facilities (1-3 months). The company maintains a revolving credit facility of 2,200 million baht for operational needs. As of December 31, 2024, the unused portion of this facility amounted to 2,000 million baht (compared to 900 million baht on December 31, 2023). This strengthens the company's financial position in the long term, reduces the risk of liquidity shortages that could hinder operations or debt servicing, and contributes to a consistently low debt-to-equity ratio (D/E), which currently stands at 0.11. • On April 20, 2023, the company established A Siam Infra Co., Ltd. (a subsidiary), with a 68.50% ownership stake. This joint venture with Hanshin Expressway Co., Ltd., KFC Co., Ltd., and AKROS Trading Co., Ltd. (experts from Japan) aims to provide inspection and maintenance services for bridges, expressways, elevated roads, and other infrastructure. This initiative will create an additional revenue stream for the company. | Toll revenue for the Don Muang Tollway under the Highway Concession Agreement is considered the Company’s main revenue. Therefore, if the Company is impacted by external factors that are uncontrollable by the Company, such as economic and political conditions, political rallies, oil prices, disasters, serious epidemics, etc., that may have significant impacts on traffic volumes on the Tollway and if the Company earns far less than the estimated revenue, it may affect the Company’s cash flow and financial liquidity, including the operating expenses under the Highway Concession Agreement. | 761 · Description: Insufficient sources of funding · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK |
| Liquidity risks | Following the allocation of 140 million baht from the sale of newly issued ordinary shares to repay loans and interest to financial institutions on May 10, 2021, the company has maintained a revolving credit facility for operational needs. This facility is reviewed annually. As of December 31, 2023 and 2024, the company secured revolving credit lines of 1,700 million baht and 2,200 million baht, respectively. The company effectively manages financial costs and investment returns. As of December 31, 2024, the company maintained a consistently low debt-to-equity ratio (D/E) of 0.11. Current liabilities amounted to 586.01 million baht, while current assets totaled 686.77 million baht, resulting in a liquidity ratio of 1.17. Of the current liabilities, 386.01 million baht are non-interest bearing, while 200.00 million baht are interest-bearing from utilizing the revolving credit facility. The company holds short-term and long-term investments, along with cash, totaling 981.09 million baht. Therefore, despite potential impacts from domestic and international economic conditions, regional conflicts, the economic slowdown following the COVID-19 pandemic, rising energy prices, or potential future outbreaks, the company maintains a strong and stable long-term financial position. As of 31 December 2024, the Company has no interest-bearing financial liabilities and a reserve revolving limit from various banks, which has not yet been drawn, of Baht 2,200 million (31 December 2023: Baht 900 million). From the financial results as of December 31, 2024 The company has a net profit per share of 0. 76 baht, ratio EBITDA Margin and NPAT Margin is equal to percentage 76. 75 and Percentage 3 6 .59 respectively The debt status has a debt-to-equity ratio of 0.11 times and a liquidity ratio of 1.17 times. Including receiving a credit line or revolving fund of 2,200 million baht, which has not yet been used as a total amount 2,000 million baht (2566 : 900 million baht ) resulting in no liquidity risk whatsoever and being able to steadily overcome various crises in the long term, creating sustainable returns for shareholders. | Following the allocation of 140 million baht from the sale of newly issued ordinary shares to repay loans and interest to financial institutions on May 10, 2021, the company has maintained a revolving credit facility for operational needs. This facility is reviewed annually. As of December 31, 2023 and 2024, the company secured revolving credit lines of 1,700 million baht and 2,200 million baht, respectively. The company effectively manages financial costs and investment returns. As of December 31, 2024, the company maintained a consistently low debt-to-equity ratio (D/E) of 0.11. Current liabilities amounted to 586.01 million baht, while current assets totaled 686.77 million baht, resulting in a liquidity ratio of 1.17. Of the current liabilities, 386.01 million baht are non-interest bearing, while 200.00 million baht are interest-bearing from utilizing the revolving credit facility. The company holds short-term and long-term investments, along with cash, totaling 981.09 million baht. Therefore, despite potential impacts from domestic and international economic conditions, regional conflicts, the economic slowdown following the COVID-19 pandemic, rising energy prices, or potential future outbreaks, the company maintains a strong and stable long-term financial position. | 1724 · Description: Liquidity risk · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK |
| Climate and environmental change risks towards measures to reduce greenhouse gases emissions | The impacts of global warming have resulted in rapid and severe changes in the current climate, causing natural disasters and environmental problems that may result in damages on property, business resource management, and customer service. In addition, many sectors place great importance on managing global warming problems. As in Thailand, the Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC) has been set in accordance with the Paris Agreement framework and has declared its commitment to fully advancing resolving climate problems in order to achieve the goal of being Carbon Neutral by 2050 and the goal of net zero emissions by 2065. This results in an adaptation to a low-carbon society by accelerating the development of clean technologies and the expectations of stakeholders in by being aware and participate in managing this problem. The Company has improved the greenhouse gas reduction target to be in line with Thailand’s ambitions in COP27 meeting, using 2022 data as the base year. For the overview of business operations in 2024, The Company organized a meeting to monitor the progress of the 3Rs (Reuse Reduce Recycle) Working Group according to the 2023-2027 Sustainable Business Plan every 2 months. The 3Rs Working Group carried out all activities that promoted the Company's participation in reducing greenhouse gases, such as waste and waste management projects, energy management projects, projects to promote the use of electric vehicles (EV Car), Green Building certification projects, Green Office assessment projects, and the procurement of environmentally friendly products. Summary of overall performance Waste management was able to recycle more than 14 percent of waste, while water usage was still higher than last year because the automatic faucet system was being installed by the Green Building project. The installation of the Solar Rooftop system began in September 2023, which resulted in the Company saving more than 30 percent of solar power, allowing the Company to continuously reduce expenses from now on. Measures to reduce paper use Performance results Reducing paper use by 39 percent In terms of procurement of environmentally friendly products, more than 82 percent of procurements were carried out. Summary of the results of the organization's carbon footprint review The Company has conducted a review of the data for 2023 as a baseline (Scoop 1, Scoop 2 and Scoop 3) equal to 3,504 tCo2e per year, for which the Company received the carbon footprint certification for 2023 from the Greenhouse Gas Management Organization (Public Organization) on May 9, 2024. In addition, the Company also cultivates employees in the organization to apply their knowledge and experience to create value for society, raise awareness in resource utilization to elevate and develop the quality of life for everyone sustainably by laying down a roadmap as a commitment to drive towards a low-carbon organization, as well as supporting participation in greenhouse gas reduction activities in the future. In 2024, the Company hired Wave BCG Co., Ltd. as a project consultant to provide advice and planning on reducing greenhouse gases from operations to achieve the Company's Carbon Neutral and Net Zero Emission goals. The objectives are 1) to create basic knowledge and understanding about greenhouse gas emissions and the impact on climate change among employees in the organization; 2) to set a strategic plan, focusing on studying and analyzing the feasibility of greenhouse gas reduction operations; and 3) to focus on reducing greenhouse gases to achieve operational goals. The company organized a training program on Corporate Carbon Footprint for one group of executives. The training covered the definition of greenhouse gases and climate change, the process of calculating a Corporate Carbon Footprint (CFO), emission scopes 1, 2, and 3, Thai and international standards, and the impact on the supply chain. It also included analyzing significant issues (hotspots), setting and measuring KPIs for reducing the corporate carbon footprint, and exploring tools for offsetting emissions, such as carbon credits and Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs). On May 1, 2024, the company established a working group for climate change management and corporate carbon footprint management (CFO). This working group received training covering the definition of greenhouse gases, the meaning of a corporate carbon footprint (CFO), emission scopes 1, 2, and 3, calculation steps, and methods for quantifying and reporting the corporate carbon footprint, including data collection. Additionally, two workshops were conducted to analyze hotspots identified in the carbon footprint assessment and to analyze risks and opportunities. To further promote awareness and understanding of the corporate carbon footprint among employees and encourage their participation in reducing greenhouse gas emissions, the company conducted four additional training sessions for employees at the operational level. Furthermore, the company successfully underwent a corporate carbon footprint (CFO) verification for 2024 and received a certificate of permission to use the CFO label from the Thailand Greenhouse Gas Management Organization (TGO). The company analyzes the impact and assesses the risks and opportunities associated with climate change, both internally and externally, following the National Determined Contributions (NDCs) and the goal of limiting global warming to below 2 degrees Celsius. The company also analyzes risks related to policy and regulatory changes to ensure its operations comply with regulations and maintain maximum efficiency. Wave BCG Co., Ltd. was hired to conduct a study on potential risks and impacts related to climate change. The company's Emergency Response and Business Continuity Planning (BCP) team monitors and reports on disaster situations quarterly, covering various events such as floods, storms, earthquakes, droughts, epidemics, and PM2.5 air pollution. These reports are submitted to the Risk Management Committee. Additionally, the team assesses climate change-related risks and reports them to the Risk Management Committee every quarter. Due to the impact of global warming, countries worldwide are actively working to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Calculating a Corporate Carbon Footprint (CFO) is one way to quantify these emissions from an organization's operations, enabling effective management strategies to reduce emissions from various activities such as fuel combustion, electricity consumption, waste management, and transportation. These emissions are calculated in tons of carbon dioxide equivalent. The company has adopted the TCFD (Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures) framework, which is used by leading companies globally to analyze climate-related risks that could impact their business. Based on this framework, the company has developed a risk management plan as follows: 1. Transition Risk: This encompasses risks associated with legal, regulatory, and policy changes, such as the introduction of new laws or regulations to control greenhouse gas emissions. These could include carbon taxes, the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), and technological shifts. Increased costs for investing in emission reduction technologies and changes in consumer preferences could also lead to higher operating costs for the company. 2. Physical Risk: This category includes operational risks and acute disasters (with a medium to long-term timeframe of 3-10 years). These risks involve the increasing severity of natural disasters such as floods, storms, droughts, water scarcity, and wildfires due to rising temperatures. Exposure to atmospheric dust and airborne allergens, especially in hot weather, can also impact work efficiency. Physical risks can affect the supply chain, leading to higher raw material prices, damage to facilities and property, and revenue impacts due to changes in consumer demand. Additionally, insurance costs and carbon taxes contribute to the financial implications of physical risks. | The impacts of global warming have resulted in rapid and severe changes in the current climate, causing natural disasters and environmental problems that may result in damages on property, business resource management, and customer service. In addition, many sectors place great importance on managing global warming problems. As in Thailand, the Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC) has been set in accordance with the Paris Agreement framework and has declared its commitment to fully advancing resolving climate problems in order to achieve the goal of being Carbon Neutral by 2050 and the goal of net zero emissions by 2065. This results in an adaptation to a low-carbon society by accelerating the development of clean technologies and the expectations of stakeholders in by being aware and participate in managing this problem. The Company has improved the greenhouse gas reduction target to be in line with Thailand’s ambitions in COP27 meeting, using 2022 data as the base year. | 750 · Description: Climate change and disasters · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1717 · Description: ESG risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Social and Human Rights Risks | Social practice Focus on building strength and sustainable growth by giving value and importance to employees, in believing that quality employees are the most important factor in leading the organization towards sustainable growth and success, as well as determining to conduct business with the community, society and the environment in a sustainable way. Therefore, the Company continuously improves and develops production processes and services in order to perform work safely and without affecting the community and society with additional risk management as follows: • In 2022-2024, the company continuously developed its occupational health and safety system in accordance with the international standard ISO 45001:2018. This aimed to improve workplace health and safety and to enhance work processes by considering risks, opportunities, and legal requirements. • Manage operational risks through the system of the Safety, Health and Environment in the Workplace Committee continuously, covering equipment, processes, and working environments. • Conduct a Hazard and Operability Study to assess and identify occupational hazards, and plan a safety management system in every step involved so that the work processes meet international standards. • Organize activities to educate, understand, and instill safety awareness in communities and societies near the Company’s business areas, especially schools with training on evacuation, fire fighting, fire escape, and installation of fire extinguishers. In addition, the Company monitors and follows up on risks that may arise and affect communities and society in each area. In order to prevent the community or society in that area from suffering or be affected by work processes, the Company continuously monitors risks associated with wastewater management and organizes CSR activities with the community and society to increase positive impacts by promoting skills, creating opportunities, and uplifting quality of society and communities in terms of education, good health, road safety, quality of life and environment according to the Company’s 5 aspects of social activities. The Risk Management Committee and the corporate governance working team are responsible for monitoring the performance throughout the year. Participation in community and social development In developing quality of community, society, and environment, the Company shall conduct its business with responsibilities without causing negative impacts on the community and the environment by supporting community and social activities. The Company focuses on quality development of community, society and environment to conduct social activities in parallel with creating economic growth, building relationships with community, and improving community in order to create a balance of sustainable development and create share values together. The Company also gives opportunities to communities and societies directly and indirectly affected by its business operations to make suggestions and complaints on various issues in order for the Company to find solutions. At the same time, the Company has used the results obtained from the community and society satisfaction survey as a guideline and consideration of activities and projects to appropriately respond to the needs of the community in terms of social and environmental aspects and to truly meet their needs. The Company conducted relationship-building and social activities in all 5 aspects, and has disclosed operating results in the company's sustainability report. Human rights practice The Company conducts its business with integrity by adhering to social responsibility and all groups of stakeholders according to the principles of corporate governance and the Company’s code of conduct. In terms of human rights protection, the Company strictly complies with the laws and international principles, in particular supporting and complying with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGP), and the International Labor Organization Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work (ILO) to ensure that the Company’s business operations are free from human rights violation. The Board of Directors deemed appropriate to establish human rights policies to prevent human rights violations such as human trafficking, forced labor, child labor, discrimination, and harassment in all direct activities of the Company and its Business Partner in Business Value Chain. The Company respects and protects human rights of employees and stakeholders by strictly ensuring that the business does not involve in violations of human rights as specified by the laws and related agencies. For human resource management, including recruitment, employment, remuneration, development, promotion, and transfers, shall be no discrimination and equal opportunities are provided regardless of race, skin color, gender, language, religion, place of origin, and political views or any other status. The Company takes into account illegal labours, participation in caring and protecting the safety of the community and society, personal rights protection, disclosure and use of personal information, as well as respect for equality and consideration for human dignity. In order to ensure that the Company’s business operations are free from violations of human rights and the right to work, as well as providing fairness and individual protection regarding human rights related to the Company, the Company implements the protection measures for complainants as specified in the “Anti-Corruption Policy and Measures for Receiving Whistleblowing or Complaints.” If anyone commits a violation, they will be subject to disciplinary action according to the regulations set by the Company and may be punished according to the law if applicable. In addition, the Company participated in the project to promote and develop the quality of life of the disabled under section 35 of the Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities Act B.E 2550 (2007) with the Chamber of Commerce and Board of Trade of Thailand and COERR Foundation by providing training courses on occupations in agriculture and animal husbandry to create occupations for disabled in the area to have a local supplementary career, be self-reliant, feel proud, and generate income for their families. The Company has operated this project continuously since 2017. | The Company conducts its business with integrity by adhering to social responsibility and all groups of stakeholders according to the principles of corporate governance and the Company’s code of conduct. In terms of human rights protection, the Company strictly complies with the laws and international principles, in particular supporting and complying with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGP), and the International Labor Organization Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work (ILO) to ensure that the Company’s business operations are free from human rights violation. The Board of Directors deemed appropriate to establish human rights policies to prevent human rights violations such as human trafficking, forced labor, child labor, discrimination, and harassment in all direct activities of the Company and its Business Partner in Business Value Chain. The Company respects and protects human rights of employees and stakeholders by strictly ensuring that the business does not involve in violations of human rights as specified by the laws and related agencies. For human resource management, including recruitment, employment, remuneration, development, promotion, and transfers, shall be no discrimination and equal opportunities are provided regardless of race, skin color, gender, language, religion, place of origin, and political views or any other status. | 753 · Description: Impact on human rights · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Good Corporate Governance Risks | As a listed company on the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the company must adhere to and enhance its corporate governance practices in accordance with the regulations and guidelines promoted by regulatory bodies and stakeholders who prioritize good governance and ethical business conduct. Failure to comply with these regulations and guidelines could damage the company's reputation and erode trust among customers, business partners, suppliers, communities, society, and regulatory authorities. Moreover, if the company conducts business without fairness, transparency, or integrity, and if the Board of Directors and management act irresponsibly, it will inevitably hinder business growth. For example, in selecting business partners, the company has established clear and fair policies and processes, prohibiting bid rigging, rejecting incentives that could influence partner selection, and ensuring fair and accurate payment for goods and services to partners. To manage corporate governance risks, the Board of Directors has appointed the Audit Committee to oversee and monitor the company's operations, ensuring compliance with good corporate governance principles. The Sustainability Governance Working Group (E/S/CG Working Team) is responsible for driving and implementing the company's corporate governance initiatives. This ensures that operations align with relevant regulations, laws, and good corporate governance principles set by regulatory bodies. The company also focuses on developing a corporate governance system that connects stakeholders, including shareholders, the Board of Directors, management, and employees. This system ensures that all parties understand and fulfill their roles and responsibilities in accordance with ethical business practices. In 2024, the Audit Committee held two meetings to monitor the company's corporate governance. The Sustainability Governance Working Group convened four meetings to track progress and implementation of its work plan. The company updated its corporate governance manual and reviewed and revised the charters of the Board of Directors and its subcommittees for 2024, aligning them with the updated policies and manual. The company also reviewed and revised its policy and procedures for related party transactions to ensure clarity, transparency, and accountability in transactions with subsidiaries or other related parties. Furthermore, the company encourages the Sustainability Governance Working Group and relevant teams to participate in ongoing training and seminars on good corporate governance. This promotes sustainable business development and aligns with stakeholder expectations. | As a listed company on the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the company must adhere to and enhance its corporate governance practices in accordance with the regulations and guidelines promoted by regulatory bodies and stakeholders who prioritize good governance and ethical business conduct. Failure to comply with these regulations and guidelines could damage the company's reputation and erode trust among customers, business partners, suppliers, communities, society, and regulatory authorities. Moreover, if the company conducts business without fairness, transparency, or integrity, and if the Board of Directors and management act irresponsibly, it will inevitably hinder business growth. For example, in selecting business partners, the company has established clear and fair policies and processes, prohibiting bid rigging, rejecting incentives that could influence partner selection, and ensuring fair and accurate payment for goods and services to partners. | 759 · Description: Corporate Governance · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 1717 · Description: ESG risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Anti-Corruption Risks | Factors and measures to prevent anti-corruption risks As a large-scale organization with a long-term concession from the Department of Highways, the company interacts with various government agencies, private organizations, and individuals, creating opportunities for corruption and bribery in collaborations and business dealings. The company is committed to conducting business with integrity, transparency, and ethical practices, upholding its social responsibility and accountability to all stakeholders in accordance with good corporate governance principles and ethical business conduct. This commitment aims to foster sustainable growth for the organization. Risk management in relation to corruption is crucial for achieving these goals. The company has implemented various policies, guidelines, and measures to prevent corruption risks, as detailed below: 1. Review, amend, and add content and operational procedures in the Anti-Corruption Policy and Whistleblowing Procedure, which is considered as one of the important policies in the Corporate Governance Manual, with an objective of defining definitions and operation processes according to the policy to be more apparent and complete. 2. Prepare an annual report in line with the good corporate governance strategy and anti-corruption measures to become an organization that manages its business with transparency and virtue. 3. Review compliance with legal policies and corruption risk assessment forms from every department in the Company and report the risk management results in this matter to the Risk Management Committee on a quarterly basis, including a report summarizing the results of reviewing corruption risks to the Audit Committee every quarter. 4. Communicate to create understanding about the Company's Code of Conduct Policy and Anti-Corruption Policy, including measures for receiving whistleblowing or complaints through various communication channels or activities for the Company's internal personnel and general public users to be aware of and have access to such policies, using various methods of implementation, such as publishing the Anti-Corruption Policy and Whistleblowing Procedure on the Company's website, communicating via e-mail to business partners, announcing the No Gift Policy on the Company's website to inform stakeholders of the Company's operations, etc. Whistleblowing Measures Provide opportunities for directors, executives, employees, business partners, and stakeholders (“complainant” or “whistleblower”) to file a complaint on unlawful acts against regulations and the Company’s business ethics, which leads to deterioration in its assets and reputation, through whistleblowing channels provided as specified in the Whistleblowing Compliant Policy. The Corporate Governance Committee is responsible for appointing a committee for investigation, who has no conflicts of interest in the complaints, in order to scrutinize such leads or complaints. Scope of whistleblowing - Any act involving unlawful gains, including embezzlement, corruption, and bribery. - Fraud-related behavior or window dressing financial statements intentionally to deceive others by showing false statements or concealing the truth. - Behaviors related to transactions that violate the law, rules and regulations of the Company and business ethics. - Conduct of suspicious nature in connection with money laundering, window dress of accounting, finance, procurement, employment, and illegal operations that damage the Company’s reputation. - Actions that lead to conflicts of interest with the Company. In 2024, the company did not encounter any instances of corruption and received no complaints or whistleblowing reports related to corruption through any of its channels. | As a large-scale organization with a long-term concession from the Department of Highways, the company interacts with various government agencies, private organizations, and individuals, creating opportunities for corruption and bribery in collaborations and business dealings. The company is committed to conducting business with integrity, transparency, and ethical practices, upholding its social responsibility and accountability to all stakeholders in accordance with good corporate governance principles and ethical business conduct. This commitment aims to foster sustainable growth for the organization. Risk management in relation to corruption is crucial for achieving these goals. The company has implemented various policies, guidelines, and measures to prevent corruption risks. | 754 · Description: Corruption · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Emerging Risks (ER) | The company conducts an annual review of various issues and trends of changes for analyzing potential new risks and risks to business operations to develop measures and guidelines for managing and responding to risks in a timely manner. In 2023, the Company by the Risk Management Working Team analyzed and identified emerging risks, as well as their impacts on the business as follows: • Risks from changes in consumer behavior Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many government and private agencies have adjusted their work patterns to allow work from home in order to reduce the risk of infection from travel and daily life. This may result in a decrease in the number of service users due to such factors and behaviors. Currently, many private agencies are still continuing to operate. • Risks from climate change the effects of global warming have caused the current climate to change rapidly and severely, which causes natural disasters and environmental problems in many areas of the country, such as rainstorms, floods, PM2.5, and changes in laws related to climate change, etc. All of which affect resource management in business operations and may cause damage to the Company’s assets and may impact its services to tollway users. Therefore, the Company must monitor and be prepared to handle such changes accordingly. • Risks from changes in innovation and new technologies new technologies and innovations have been implemented to improve business processes and to provide products or services to facilitate and respond to needs of new generation consumers, which change and develop quickly. Therefore, in order for the Company to be responsive and increase its competitiveness, studies and development of new innovations are continuously conducted, as well as applying them in the Company’s work processes while constantly monitors various changes in innovation and technology. | The company conducts an annual review of various issues and trends of changes for analyzing potential new risks and risks to business operations to develop measures and guidelines for managing and responding to risks in a timely manner. In 2023, the Company by the Risk Management Working Team analyzed and identified emerging risks, as well as their impacts on the business. | 1717 · Description: ESG risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |

