DON MUANG TOLLWAY PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: DMT🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Board of Directors realizes the importance of a good internal control system and is an important duty to ensure that the Company implements an appropriate and sufficient internal control system to effectively supervise the operations in accordance with the goals, objectives, laws and related regulations, as well as protecting assets from corruption, damages. In addition, preparation of accounting and financial reports must be accurate, credible, and disclosed in a complete, adequate, and timely manner.

The Board of Directors’ Meeting No. 1/2024, held on 21 February 2024, attended by 4 independent directors, of which 3 were members of the Audit Committee. The Board of Directors considered adequacy of the Company’s internal control system with the Audit Committee and executives according to the guideline framework of The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of Treadway Commission (“COSO”) with 17 principles in all 5 aspects. It was concluded that the Company’s internal control system is sufficient and suitable for supervising implementation of the goals and good CG principles, in which the key points can be summarized below:

1. Control Environment

The Board of Directors and executives support organizational culture that focuses on integrity and ethics in its operations, as well as ensuring the Company’s business respects the vision and mission with a good internal control environment and facilitates compliance with the following internal control system policies:

1.1 The Board of Directors and executives has determined the Company’s CG policy consisting of 3 main parts, namely the Code of Conduct, guidelines for good corporate governance principles, and important policies on corporate governance, which can be found in the Good Corporate Governance Handbook for directors, executives, and employees to adhere to as guidelines for their work. Every employee is responsible for internal control and to maintain the internal control system. In this regard, the Company has communicated and announced to all employees for acknowledgment and compliance with better understanding via the Company’s website and orientation of new personnel.

1.2 The Board of Directors is knowledgeable of the Company’s business with expertise beneficial to the Company, including being independent from the management, to oversee the overall business operations, provide opinions on the Company’s strategic direction to use as a guideline for making business and action plans, and follow up on performances of the Company and ad hoc committees on a regular basis in order to ensure that its defined targets are achieved.

1.3 The Company defines its organizational structure in the form of line of work in accordance with the organization’s business strategies and plans, including changing business conditions, by assigning duties and responsibilities in a written form. The Table of Authority has been established to limit the authority of the Board and executives in approving operations or transactions, to determine the annual plan and Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) as a guideline for employees, and to regularly monitor performance against targets. The annual goals are reviewed for all employees to acknowledge on their roles, duties, and responsibilities by performing evaluation on performance and behaviors. The evaluation results will be used as supporting information for consideration of remuneration as an incentive for performance, in which strengths and areas of improvement as reported to employees appropriately.

1.4 The Company has a human resource management policy for recruiting persons with knowledge, capabilities, and required qualifications, as well as to continuously promote and develop personnel to use their maximum potential while performing their tasks. The Company also has a process of recruiting, developing, and retaining executives and employees of all levels, including plans and processes for recruitment and succession plan to enable business continuity.

2. Risk Assessment

The Board of Directors and executives emphasize on risk management to build confidence in steering the organization to achieve short-term and long-term goals. Therefore, the Risk Management Committee has been appointed by the Board as well as the risk management working team to oversee that the Company’s risk management is appropriate and effective. Risk management guidelines under the “Risk Management and Risk Factors” are as follows:

2.1 The Company operates risk management throughout the organization following the COSO Enterprise Risk Management framework. The risk management policy has been set as a part of the CG policy, including the risk management handbook which is communicated to executives and employees at all levels to acknowledge and comply, and making it one of the organization’s culture. In addition, the Company’s financial reports have been prepared according to reliable accounting standards, reflecting the organization’s activities and are audited by an external certified auditor.

2.2 The Company shall review risks from internal and external factors, including the potential for fraud and corruption which covers strategic risks, operations (concession agreements), finance, compliance with legal policies, network and project management of information technology, and sustainability development by assessing both the likelihood of occurrence and level of impact. The Key Risk Indicator (KRI) is used in the process of monitoring the chances of such risks in order to improve and formulate additional risk management plans to reduce the impact on the organization’s goals and to control critical organizational risks to an acceptable level to achieve the goals.

2.3 The Company has established a Business Continuity Plan (BCP) and Disaster Recovery Plan (DRP), in which emergency plan training on information systems is conducted annually by simulating situations that affect the security of information and cyber attack such as data leaks, hacks into the Company’s information system by outsiders which may interrupt business operations and damage its reputation. The training is performed together with relevant departments to prepare for risks and crises that may arise, as well as making sure that the Company’s key operations will continue without interruption. In every quarter, performance of the risk management committee is reported to the audit committee and the Board of Directors. Internal auditors review and inspect if mitigation measures are being followed in order to ensure that the Company’s risks are at an acceptable and manageable level.

2.4 The Company has implemented the Business Continuity Management (BCM) during the COVID-19 outbreak by the Pandemic Emergency Management committee to asses operational guidelines, communicate to employees, prepare resources and systems for employees to work seamlessly with safety and no impact on key goals.

2.5 The Company reviewed the Company’s strategies, both short-term and long-term, to be in line with changing business environment by taking into consideration its maximum benefits and sustainability. The internal control regularly reviews sufficiency and suitability of the internal control system, which covers operational processes that are significant as well.

3. Control Activities

The Company has internal control activities that are clear and appropriate to the risks and nature of business, which help reduce the risks of not achieving the Company’s objectives to an acceptable level as follows:

3.1 The Company applies the balanced scorecard and KPIs as tools for planning, controlling, verifying, and monitoring with a manual on business ethics and work practices, including CG policy for all employees to follow and aware of since the orientation of new personnel.

3.2 The Company has established operational controls in manuals and procedures of various work processes such as setting the level and limit of approval authority, designating responsibilities for approval, recording transactions or income-expense, completely separate inspecting and managing of assets. There is an internal control on finance, accounting, collection, saving, bank deposits, and advance loan to be in accordance with the prescribed regulations with accounting records that are complete, accurate, and consistent. Accounting documents and information are stored systematically and in compliance with the laws in order to check and balance. Also, there are control measures for both preventive and detecting abnormalities.

3.3 The Company controls risks related to information technology by establishing information technology security policy for employees of all levels to be aware of the system safety. The security concerns control, accessibility of each level, password setting, information back-up and recovery for business continuity, and use of information in order to prevent modification or misuse of information or illegally, as well as storage of computer traffic data according to the Computer-Related Offenses Act B.E. 2550 (2007).

3.4 The policy to prevent conflicts of interest is a part of the CG policy which prohibits directors, executives, and employees from seeking personal gains. The rules for connected transactions of the Company is used as a guideline in the event that the Company has transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest or connected persons according to the rules and notification of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the Securities and Exchange Commission. The Office of Internal Audit is responsible for reviewing sufficiency and suitability of the control system on a regular basis by stipulating that the audit plan covers important operational processes.

4. Information and Communication

The Company places importance on efficient information management systems by providing an information system and communication channels that can thoroughly connect both internal and external data communication, which is essential to business operation to meet the specified objectives. The guidelines for information and communication management are as follows:

4.1 The Company uses accurate and up-to-date information with adequate details for decision makings of significant issues during meetings, in which the Company collects and considers related information from both inside and outside the organization. Various agencies must submit appropriate information to be verified before use. Moreover, the Company has defined classes of secrecy, guidelines for storing important documents and control documents by using software for collecting and processing information in all aspects to reduce duplication and enhance speed of analysis to be reported to the management.

4.2 The Company appropriately communicates with the Board of Directors, executives, employees, and stakeholders, in which key matters relating to operating results and meeting documents are sent to the Board of Directors prior to the meeting within the period specified by the law in order for the Board to study or inquire additional information from the management, to analyze various information thoroughly before making an adequate decision, including preparing meeting minutes which consists of consideration results, questions and opinions of the Board by certifying the minutes of meeting in the next meeting. The Company also organizing various internal communication channels such as announcements, Town Hall meetings, the Company’s intranet, emails, and mobile application, and orientation of new employees.

4.3 Disclosure of complete and timely information to shareholders and investors are conducted regularly by the Investor Relations. Such relevant information are general information, financial information, investment, and other key information that may affect shareholders, etc. which are communicated via various media namely the Company’s website, emails, publications, shareholders’ meeting, etc., including disclosure of information through the Stock Exchange of Thailand.

4.4 All groups of stakeholders can submit complaints through various channels. The chairman of the corporate governance working team considers, evaluates, and resolves complaints or leads received with parties involved in such complaints and then report to the Board of Directors or the person assigned by the Board of Directors for further acknowledgment. According to the Whistle Blowing Procedure, stakeholders can make connect through the Company’s website www.tollway.co.th, under Whistle Blowing, or contact the Company Secretary at email: www.companysecretary.co.th or the complaint box located at the lobby hall of the Company’s head office.

5. Monitoring Activities

The Company monitors and assesses sufficiency of internal control, as well as setting improvement guidelines to ensure that the Company’s internal control system is effective and efficient as follows:

5.1 The management of each unit is responsible for overseeing operations within its own unit and provide a system to continuously monitor performance by setting out in normal operations to respond to changing situations, have adequate internal control, track employees’ performance through KPIs, and measure results using Balanced Scorecard to motivate performance. In the event that the actual results differ from the plans or specified criteria, analyze for cause and formulate corrective guidelines within a reasonable period of time.

5.2 The Company has continuously performed compliance monitoring and reporting to improve the process of monitoring compliance with laws, rules, regulations, and assessments to evaluate compliance risks with legal policies.

5.3 The management must report directly to the Board of Directors immediately in cases of suspicion of frauds, violation of laws, or other unusual actions that may significantly affect the Company’s reputation and financial position. The report of material deficiencies along with solutions is submitted to the Board of Directors or the Audit Committee within a reasonable period of time for consideration.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkOther — Please SpecifyDetail
OtherThe Company’s office of internal audit has a duty to verify the internal control system and good corporate governance, in which the Audit Committee oversees the operations of the office of internal audit to be independent, comply with the charter of the office of internal audit and the International Professional Practices Framework (IPPF) for inspecting and reporting, including a balanced administrative power. Mr. Preecha Samuhawattanachai is the head of the office of internal control and secret

Inspection of the Company’s internal control system is for checking various work systems and processes to make sure that the internal control system is appropriate and adequate for performing effective operations to achieve goals. The inspection focuses on important and high-risk work systems such as the toll collection system (random inspection every 6 months), the procurement system, the information technology control and management system, the financial control and management system, and the fixed asset control and management system, etc. Moreover, the Company’s compliance with good corporate governance principles is reviewed twice a year.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)000

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

Yes

Auditor's Observations

Remarks from the auditor

From the audit of the Company’s financial statements for the year 2024, KPMG Phoomchai Audit Company Limited, the Company’s auditor, had no remarks on the internal control system in a material manner that may cause damage to the Company’s operations in any way.

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3159

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the Head of Internal Audit has sufficient education and experience to apply such knowledge and judgment in planning, analyzing, evaluating, reasoning, and communicating the tasks under their responsibilities by operating according to professional standards for internal auditing and auditing plans. The Audit Committee considered the performance of the Head of Internal Audit and the budget of the Office of the Internal Audit to have resources and training necessary for the skills, abilities, and responsiveness with the changes of the current circumstances.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

Appointment, removal, and transfer of the Head of Internal Audit position will be considered and approved by the Audit Committee by taking into account qualifications of the position and related practices according to the Company’s regulations and appropriateness in:

• Knowledge and experience necessary for internal audit tasks.

• Morality, professional ethics, and comply with the regulations of the Company.

• Skills in communication and coordination with internal and external personnel and agencies.

• Ability to manage the tasks of the Internal Audit Office to achieve the goals according to the plans and in line with the Company’s direction, as well as performing other tasks assigned by the Audit Committee.

• Continuously develop own self and team members in order for internal audit tasks to be an effective control mechanism.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Mr. Rawat ChamchalermPerson

The Company’s director holding the positions of Vice Chairman, Chairman of the Executive Committee, and legal advisor.

2024-12-31T00:00
FWD General Insurance Public Company Limited Juristic PersonINSURANCE

One joint director, Mr. Kulvat Janvatanavit, is an executive director of the Company and a director and holds 10% of FWD General Insurance Public Company Limited shares.

2024-12-31T00:00
Kiatnakin Phatra Securities Public Company LimitedJuristic PersonSelf-employed securities and investment derivatives broker

Mr. Banyong Pongpanich/2 was the Company’s independent director and Chairman of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, who resigned on 28 February 2021, and holds a Chairman of the Board of Directors position at Kiatnakin Phatra Securities Public Company Limited.

2024-12-31T00:00
ASIAM Infra Company LimitedJuristic Personbusiness of inspection, measurement, analysis, evaluation, design and planning for maintenance, including repairs and improvements, and strengthening various infrastructures and sales of related materials

Subsidiary company in which the Company holds 68.50% of shares.

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
0.0 · Necessity: The Company needed a legal expert as advisor on legal affairs, rules, and regulations of government agencies. Special Professor Rawat Chamchalerm is a person who possesses the experiences and qualifications required by the Company. In the past, he was appointed as Attorney General. Currently, he is a Special Professor to the Faculty of Law of Chulalongkorn University, Mae Fa Luang University, Mahidol University, Krungthep Thonburi University, and Institute of Legal Education of the Thai Bar. Besides, he holds a number of honourable positions of law in various agencies of the public and private sectors. · Description: The legal advice of Special Professor Rawat Chamchalerm was in the following areas: • Legal matters related to administrative cases • Advice on legal matters and the Concession Agreement of the current project and expansion of new projects • Legal opinions on business operations · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Legal advisory fee · Audit committee opinion: The advisory fee was reasonable, compared with the fees of legal experts of other law firms. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.08
0.0 · Necessity: The selection was based on the company's potential, capabilities, and expertise in insurance services. They demonstrate strong capacity in providing insurance-related consultations, particularly in handling various insurance claims involving employees, concession assets, and the company’s operational vehicles. Furthermore, they offer guidance and advice to help the company coordinate smoothly with government agencies, state enterprises, private sectors, and other relevant organizations. · Description: The company has selected FWD General Insurance Public Company Limited as its insurance provider, which includes property risk insurance for concession assets and motor insurance policies. · As of yesteryear: 0.42 · Nature of transaction: Insurance premium · Audit committee opinion: The premium prices paid to the insurer were suitable compared with those of other insurers in the same manner. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.73
0.0 · Necessity: The Company appointed Kiatnakin Phatra Securities Public Company Limited as the broker for the trading of securities in which the Company invests. Therefore, the Company was deemed a customer of Kiatnakin Phatra Securities Public Company Limited. The transaction made was reasonable as the Company receives maximum benefits, considering the process of the transaction and the delivery of assets as required by the Stock Exchange of Thailand; Kiatnakin Phatra Securities Public Company Limited had potential, knowledge, experiences, personnel, and expertise in financial services to investors, both in Thailand and foreign countries, and the general public. · Description: The Company appointed Kiatnakin Phatra Securities Public Company Limited as the broker for the trading of securities in which the Company invests. Therefore, the Company was deemed a customer of Kiatnakin Phatra Securities Public Company Limited. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Service fee · Audit committee opinion: The service fees paid were suitable, compared with those of other service providers in the same manner. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.04
0.0 · Necessity: The Company has considered hiring ASIAM Infra Company Limited (subsidiary), a service provider with expertise and technology suitable for repairing concrete structures for tollway. Entering into such transaction is considered a connected transaction according to the announcement of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, regarding information disclosure and operations of listed companies in connected transactions 2003. It is considered a transaction supporting normal business with general trading conditions. The price is reasonable and acceptable by both parties. · Description: The Company has considered hiring ASIAM Infra Company Limited (subsidiary), a service provider with expertise and technology suitable for repairing concrete structures for tollway. · As of yesteryear: 8.1 · Nature of transaction: Service fee · Audit committee opinion: The selection process is in accordance with procurement regulations and has general trade conditions that are reasonable and beneficial to the Company. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.45

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The Board of Directors has established policies and regulations for connected transactions and transactions between the Company and related persons or related juristic persons or juristic persons who may involve in a conflict of interest or involve a conflict of interest in the future with the Company. Therefore, the Company follows rules, regulations, and measures or procedures for approval of the Securities and Exchange Act, including announcements, rules, and relevant regulations of the Capital Market Supervisory Board, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and/or the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) in order to ensure that such transactions are transparent, not a transfer of benefits, and concern the best interests of the Company and its shareholders.

In case of entering into a transaction that may lead to a conflict of interest, the transaction shall be approved by the management, the Executive Committee or the Board of Directors or shareholders, as the case may be, with the Audit Committee considering the reasonableness of the transaction, taking into account the Company’s maximum benefits. The determination or review of the prices and conditions of transactions shall be in accordance with those of normal business transactions with fair prices or prices compared with the market price. Moreover, the stakeholders or directors of the Company’s top executives who may have a conflict of interest in a related-party transaction shall not participate in the approval of such related-party transaction.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

The Company shall comply with the rules and regulations as stipulated by SEC and SET, including practicing according to the requirements on information disclosure of related-party transactions and the acquisition or disposal of the Company’s assets or its subsidiary (if any) and according to the accounting standards established by the Federation of Accounting Professions.

If in any way a related-party transaction of the Company or its subsidiary (if any) is made with a person or a stakeholder that may involve in a conflict of interest or involve a conflict of interest in the future, the Company shall have the Audit Committee express opinions on the necessity and reasonableness of the transaction. In case of the Audit Committee does not have an expertise to consider the related-party transaction, the Audit Committee may assign an expert or the external auditor to give opinions on the related-party transaction for assisting the decision making of the Audit Committee, the Executive Committee, the Board of Directors, or the shareholders, as appropriate. The Company will disclose related-party transactions in the remark section of the financial statement audited by the Company’s external auditor.

Contents